DAVID BOWIE - Scary Monsters (Virgin)
Mar. 17th, 2004 03:17 pmI don't like the guy's voice. Never noticed it before, I think, because I'd never heard a record where his singing was *all* I disliked. Here, though, the music grabbed me (no idea if that's something special about Scary Monsters or a result of some change in me) only to leave me frustrated with Bowie's singing. It's showy and stylized with no payoff; he wants me to listen to him sing, okay, I got that part from the fact that he's singing. But he sings in a way that always tugs at the edges of my awareness, trying to pull me away from whatever else in the song I might have been focussing on but not ultimately providing any reason for it if I give in, like a 3-year-old. "Aaron! Aaron! Aaron! Aaron! Aaron!" "What?" "Um... I don't know."
Possibly I hear Bowie that way because he sounds just like that guy who did all those crappy songs on the radio when I was just starting to listen to pop music in 1982 like "Let's Dance" and "China Girl". What was THAT guy's deal? Anyway, whoever he was, I shouldn't hold the resemblance against David Bowie, the androgynous artsy envelope-pusher who recorded this record in 1980.
But I'm just not feeling it.